Middle East studies in the News
What It's Like To Attend America's First Accredited Muslim College [on Zaytuna College, incl. Hatem Bazian]
by Jack Jenkins
Professor Mahan Mirza looks out over his classroom, pausing from his lecture to gaze at the row of attentive faces stretched before him. The class is Freshman Rhetoric, and the students have just finished discussing the merits of a speech by president Ronald Reagan. Time is up, and people are already softly packing away their notebooks into book bags, barely listening as the professor ticks off the homework assignment for the next session — another speech, this time by Ted Kennedy.
The scene would probably feel commonplace to any American college student who has waited eagerly for a professor to end a lesson. But what Mirza does next is something altogether different: before dismissing the class, he closes his eyes, bows his head, and recites an Islamic prayer in Arabic.
All the students stop for a moment, then bow their heads solemnly as well — because every one of them is Muslim.
There are a few hints that this may not be an average college classroom, of course. The small lecture hall is split down the middle between men and women, a firm gender separation accented by flashes of Islamic tradition: some of the men wear Muslim garb and head coverings, and most women are wrapped in brightly colored hijabs. But a few wear their hair exposed and flowing, and a majority of the men are clad in hoodies, t-shirts, and the occasional Steelers jacket. What's more, the dynamics are roughly the same as you would find in any co-ed college classroom, albeit with an unusually high level of gender parity: men and women spoke roughly equal time over the course of Mirza's lecture, never once interrupting each other.
Such is the uncommon atmosphere of Zaytuna College, America's first — and currently, only — accredited Muslim college, located in Berkeley, California. Founded in 2009, the tiny but growing school touts itself as singularly focused on fusing the western concept of the liberal arts — where students are steeped in classical logic and rhetoric — with a distinctly Islamic education that requires, among other things, proficiency in Quranic studies.
And aside from gender-divided classes, there are other, less-visible signals that the school is working to balance traditional academia with Muslim tradition: Islam generally abhors usury and debt, so every Zaytuna student that cannot afford tuition attends classes for free, benefitting from financial aid programs and scholarships that do not incur interest. The money comes from members of the Muslim community donating to the school as their zakat, an Islamic practice similar to Christian tradition of giving alms.
"We believe knowledge is sacred. That's part of our tradition," said Hatem Bazian, one of the leading scholars who helped found the college.
And now, as the United States endures an unprecedented wave of Islamophobia — where American Muslims are dismissed by politicians as foreign invaders — that tradition ensures Zaytuna is rapidly becoming the nation's epicenter of Islamic thought. The students it produces stand to represent the future of a decidedly American form of Islamic leadership, an increasingly important role thrust upon them as the United States struggles to embrace its growing Muslim-American population.
It's hard to find Zaytuna College, tucked away among the sunny peaks of "holy hill," a collection of seminaries and religious schools perched just above the main campus of the University of California, Berkeley. And it certainly doesn't look like a stereotypical bastion of Islamic thought.
The school's main building isn't a mosque, nor is it a shining example of traditional Islamic architecture. Rather, Zaytuna is housed in the onetime home of a United Church of Christ congregation, where the sanctuary has been retrofitted into a lecture hall and classes are held in spaces once set aside for Christian Sunday School. Worn, metal markers designating Christian church offices still hang untouched on hallway walls, and the sign out front is simply a canvass image of Zaytuna's logo wrapped tightly around a former church sign. Despite appearances, however, the church — along with another nearby building acquired from a Catholic order — now houses a growing Islamic institution, where dozens of hijab and taqiyah-clad students bustle in and out each day to pursue their studies.
Administrators admit that the property, first acquired in 2015, is something students and faculty are still getting used to. The school was originally founded in 1996 by Muslim scholars Hamza Yusuf and Hesham Alalusi as the "Zaytuna Institute" in Hayward, California, but has taken on a variety of forms over the years — including a brief stint as a Muslim seminary program, which graduated five students in 2008 — usually without a dedicated home. By 2009, the original founders felt their school would be a better fit for students at the college level, so they, along with Bazian, reimagined the institute as Zaytuna College and welcomed their first freshman class in 2010.
But unlike other centers of Muslim thought in the United States, which tend to focus solely on the study of Islam and the Quran, Zaytuna is setting out to do something altogether different. It was created with the dream of establishing an Islamic version of a classically western — and unmistakably American — institution: a faith-based liberal arts college.
"We want our students to be grounded in the Islamic tradition as far as texts, context, and to be able to engage in those debates," Bazian told ThinkProgress. "But at the same time they're functioning in a society that had a particular understanding that they need to be aware of because that's where they're living. So that's what went into the crafting of their curriculum."
The result is a tiny school — just around 60 students — that tackles the very large goal of balancing Islamic instruction alongside the "western canon," or works produced by famous philosophers such as Aristotle and Plato. It's a new take on an old system, and so far, it seems to be working: the college managed to gain accreditation with blinding speed (it was authorized by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges in 2015), and remains passionately dedicated to a unique, rigorous curriculum, which is set for all students from year one. Classes range from traditional Islamic disciplines, such as Quranic exegesis and Islamic thought, to courses more familiar to western eyes, such as rhetoric and ancient philosophy.
Sitting in front of a whiteboard covered with a mixture of Islamic verses and quotes from former U.S. Supreme Court justices, Munes Tomeh, a kinetic, bespectacled professor who teaches the school's constitutional law course, explained that classroom instruction often taps into this synthesis of holy and secular.
"I actually do try to bring theology into my constitutional law class," he said. "Islam, in terms of how it reacts to constitutionalism, or reacts to certain American articulations of constitutional thinking, and certainly the [American Founding Fathers] and how they view the constitution."
Zaytuna essentially mimics the belief-focused education modeled by America's innumerable faith-based liberal arts schools such as Wheaton College, Yeshiva University, or Gonzaga University. But Zaytuna's firm embrace of Islam instead of Christianity or Judaism is unique among the country's four-year institutions of higher learning. And the modern context in which Zaytuna operates — where militant groups wage terrorist attacks while claiming to represent Islam, and where Islamophobia has become a talking point for leading presidential candidates — has significantly raised the profile and influence of the small school.
Perhaps the most unusual — and most Muslim — aspect of the school isn't necessarily what it teaches its students, but how it forms them as people. Although Zaytuna doesn't mandate that students be Muslim ("We had one non-Muslim applicant. We accepted her. She went somewhere else," Mirza said), enrollees are encouraged to ground their activities both inside and outside the classroom in an Islamic moral framework — all while maintaining an informed worldview.
"They want to be a Muslim as well as engage any topic," Bazian said. "It doesn't weaken their Islamic understanding. If anything, it actually strengthens it."
Mark Delp, a philosophy professor at Zaytuna and one of two non-Muslims who teach at the school (he identifies as Christian), noted that students — colloquially referred to as "Zaytunis" — are often surprised by the overlap between western thought and Islamic tradition.
"Islamic philosophy, at least in the main thrust of it...It's almost identical with the Latin scholastic philosophy," he said.
Indeed, Zaytuna students like Reema Lateef — a senior who hails from Orlando, but speaks with a lilting, sing-song accent that would be right at home in Orange County, California — appear to have taken the administration's efforts to heart. Lateef explained that while she came to Zaytuna partly to "experience engaging and living around other Muslims" ("I didn't grow up around a lot of practicing Muslims in Orlando," she said), the college's marriage of liberal arts and Islam also spoke to her in a way that larger, secular colleges didn't.
"It's hard to explain to people: 'Yes, I'm attending a religious institution. But it's not to narrow my mind. It's actually to broaden my mind,'" she said. "Zaytuna, being an environment where you can have those kinds of conversations while studying the tradition while also studying its modern applicability, interested me."
"Modern applicability" is paramount for Lateef and her fellow students. Ideology and theology vary wildly among enrollees (the school is mostly affiliated with the Sunni branch of Islam, but caters to all of Islam's various permutations), but many approach Islam with a relatively liberal, social-justice minded flair. Nirav Bhardwaj, a sophomore and convert to Islam, said he was drawn to study Islamic finance at the school "to protect people from being taken advantage of." His wife Iman Hamze — a fellow Zaytuni he met at the school — serves as one of the officers on Zaytuna's student council, and volunteers at the local Islamic community center to help "make a difference."
And Lateef, who volunteers part-time at a domestic violence shelter, managed to merge her academic and real-world interests for her senior thesis, an exhaustive project required of all graduates. Her work takes a critical look at sexual consent, for both men and women, under Islamic law.
"I consider myself a feminist, and I didn't even think about feminism until I came to Zaytuna," Lateef said. "So how does a person, when studying Islamic law — which seems antithetical to principles of feminism — become interested in feminism? Well, I saw aspects of [Islamic law] that were empowering women that would fit that, and I see a need to revisit Islamic principles and laws that address the concerns of women."
Life at the college isn't always about homework and career goals, of course. Like most college youth, students find time for fun in non-academic clubs: some meet for archery practice each week, a few write stories for the school's student-run publication, and still others gather as part of a musical singing group described as "Muslim a capella." A newly installed ping-pong table has led to a number of rowdy, blistering tournaments between classes.
But for students such as Aisha Ibrahim, Zaytuna's goal of developing a new U.S. tradition of Islamic scholasticism is crucial. A native of "little Palestine" just outside Chicago, Illinois and the child of two Muslim converts — one of whom is an imam — Ibrahim rejected any notion of a conflict between her faith and nationality, describing herself "as American as you can get."
"Every time somebody asked me where I'd like to go to school I said Zaytuna," she said. "I wanted to be in a place where other people are striving for the same things. You can go to other religious institutions and you have the shared value of religion, but that doesn't necessarily mean that people are living the kind of lifestyle that you want to participate in. There are a lot of Christian and Jewish schools that you can go to hold religion in esteem...but I wanted to go somewhere where I felt safe, away from home."
In addition to their studies, Zaytuna students admitted that, as pupils at America's first Muslim college, they sometimes feel pressure to act as representatives for all U.S. Muslims. Most said that they haven't experience Islamophobia in liberal Berkeley, but cited discomfort with the growing tide of anti-Muslim hatred in the United States, especially the vitriol of Donald Trump — a phenomenon they feel obligated to resist. Several of the students had already been interviewed for news stories about American Muslims in the past, a trend they expect to increase only with time.
The school has only handed out diplomas to two classes, but administrators are quick to point to Zaytuna graduates who are already making a name for themselves as positive, public Muslim leaders. For instance, when several African American churches burned to the ground last summer in the wake of the tragic shooting in Charleston, South Carolina, news outlets noted that a Muslim organization raised more than $100,070 to help the congregations rebuild — a higher sum than several Christian organizations accumulated in the same time period. The lead organizer for the effort? Faatimah Knight, a Zaytuna graduate.
Zaytunis contend that public gestures of goodwill aren't the only way to change hearts and minds about Islam, however. Embedded in Zaytuna's academic mission is an unspoken belief that the best way to combat anti-Muslim hatred is to produce educated, productive members of American society.
"I think there's a lot of assumptions that because of all this Islamophobia, Muslims need to speak out against it. But I actually think it's more empowering to also not give legitimacy to those stereotypes," Lateef said. "I will just act. I will go to law school. Be amongst my peers who aren't Muslim. Engage with them on an equal level. I think that's the most powerful way to dispel those stereotypes, and I think a lot of our class feels that way."
Meanwhile, Zaytuna's three founders have effectively become ambassadors for American Islam, especially Hamza Yusuf, who travels the world to deliver talks to sprawling crowds. Predictably, their vocal opposition to Islamophobia has earned them criticism from the country's anti-Islam factions, some of whom try to paint the scholars as anti-American.
"I have to constantly educate wherever I go — which isn't that bad for an educator!" Bazian said.
While Zaytuna's religious teachings are deeply grounded in ancient Muslim traditions, they're already pushing boundaries in some Islamic communities — something that Tumeh noted is not unusual among American academic institutions.
"I know that a lot of what I talk about in my class would have been controversial when I was growing up in the Muslim community," he said. "So the Muslim community that they're growing up in the United States is a very different one than I grew up in."
Zaytuna's American flavor of Islamic scholarship — now imbued within a growing generation of its college graduates — is actively challenging Muslims outside the U.S., and has even stoked the fury of terrorist groups that claim to represent Islam. When militants affiliated with ISIS brutally gunned down journalists at the Paris, France-based Charlie Hebdo magazine in 2015, for instance, Yusuf was one of several American scholars to release statements condemning the attacks. When ISISpublished a recruitment magazine later that year with an article decrying certain Muslim scholars as apostates, the image alongside the text was of Yusuf, blasting him for condemning the attack.
Zaytuna is also building a bond with other American religious institutions, which tend to respect each other as faith organizations, regardless of theological differences. This affinity became apparent during a recent kerfuffle surrounding Wheaton College, a deeply conservative evangelical Christian school in Illinois. The college made headlines earlier this year when officials threatened to fire professor Larycia Hawkins after she claimed that Muslims and Christians worship the same God. The scandal sparked widespread outrage and accusations of Islamophobia, with Wheaton students and graduates — several of whom work in major media outlets — demanding the administration back off.
But when Yusuf was asked to comment on the controversy, his measured response hinted at a deep sense of solidarity. He agreed the treatment of Hawkins was inappropriate, but insisted that Wheaton should be allowed to run their school according to their own theological rules — just like any other religious institution.
"It is sad that Wheaton College took the actions that it did against [Hawkins'] beautiful act of support and solace," he wrote. "[But] people must feel free to worship and teach their faith as they see fit, and our colleges should be protected in their approaches to doing so. Wheaton College is an important institution, and this is an unfortunate blemish on its record given its inquisitorial feel, but it is a learning process they are going through navigating new waters, and we should pray for them to do the right thing."
Ultimately, Zaytuna's experiment in fusing the liberal arts with Islam is, like all new schools, an ongoing one. Success still largely depends on whether or not leaders are able to continue to accrue financial support for the college, which, in turn, hinges on the quality of their graduates. In the meantime, however, students and teachers remain adamant that their westernized Islamic institution isn't just novel, but necessary: when Bazian was asked how the college's faculty and staff should react to America's current political climate, where GOP frontrunner Donald Trump regularly spouts Islamophobic rhetoric as a vote-getting tactic, his answer cited not just Islamic teachings, but also the support of a famous Greek philosopher.
"We have to respond to the world in which we live," Bazian said. "If you read Aristotle, back when he was writing about the proclamations of his day...I imagine that if Aristotle were to hold a symposium today, he would have a lot to say about Donald Trump!"Note: Articles listed under "Middle East studies in the News" provide information on current developments concerning Middle East studies on North American campuses. These reports do not necessarily reflect the views of Campus Watch and do not necessarily correspond to Campus Watch's critique.
Campus Watch contact e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org