"Socialist Worker" Makes False Charges Against Campus Watch

by Winfield Myers  •  Jul 12, 2010 at 11:40 am
Cross-posted from Setting the Record Straight

http://www.campus-watch.org/correction/72

http://www.campus-watch.org/blog/2010/07/socialist-worker-makes-false-charges-against

Brian Napoletano, in a June 22, 2010, article in Socialist Worker (yes, it's still around), mischaracterized Campus Watch's mission when he wrote:

Organizations such as Campus Watch, a Middle East Forum project, have already invested substantial resources into identifying and attacking scholars who criticize the Israeli government's treatment of the Palestinian people, and they are still attempting to characterize the growing discontent with Israel's illegal occupation as spontaneous outbursts of 'anti-Semitism.'

Let's deal with each old Left buzzword in order:

First, CW does not, in fact, "attack" anyone for any reason. We critique scholars of the Middle East for politicized scholarship, biased presentations of their subjects, and other epistemological and pedagogical errors. For many on the far left, disagreement comes only in the form of "attacks," as if all who deign to differ with their interpretation of history are necessarily militant by nature. The fruits of false consciousness, one assumes.

Second, we do not even critique scholars who "criticize the Israeli government's treatment of the Palestinian people." Our aims are not political, nor are they petty. Unlike writers for Socialist Worker, however, we critique politically biased scholarship that somehow finds fault with only one side of the Arab-Israeli conflict while turning a blind eye toward atrocities committed by the other. We seek balance in scholarship because that quality, among others, separates true scholarly writing from propaganda.

Third, CW is far more reluctant to accuse anyone of anti-Semitism than Napoletano is to charge us and others with doing so. But on rare occasions when we decide that the charge is warranted, under no circumstances do we mischaracterize objections to Israeli policies as anti-Semitism. Such a charge against us is unfounded and therefore unprovable.

Socialist Worker is on Twitter, MySpace, and Facebook, the better to communicate with the proletariat, one assumes. Workers of the World: Tweet!

receive the latest by email: subscribe to campus watch's free mailing list This text may be reposted or forwarded so long as it is presented as an integral whole with complete information provided about its author, date, place of publication, and original URL.