Campus Watch Research
Bonfire of the Vulgarians: Middle East Studies in Decline
by Cinnamon Stillwell
A glaring example occurred in late 2014, when UC Irvine history professor Mark LeVine posted an expletive-laden, unhinged rant on Facebook calling for the destruction of Israel:
University of California, Riverside (UCR) creative writing professor Reza Aslan displays a similar penchant for profanity. During an April lecture at UCR, Aslan, responding to the obviously true statement that it's erroneous to accuse "anyone who criticizes Islam of being Islamophobic," retorted: "That's bulls—!"
Aslan displays the same wit on Twitter, where he's hurled epithets at political opponents, such as "f—ing idiot" and "f—ing liar," while asking, "Are you f—ing joking?" and concluding, "Shut the f— up!" When asked on a May, 2014 Reddit thread what he would do if "stuck on an island" with American Freedom Defense Initiative founder Pamela Geller, Aslan, alluding to the ugly term "hate sex," answered, "I guess it's time to make some hate babies, Pam."
Yet the poster child for vitriolic, profanity-laden social media outbursts is Steven Salaita, the former Virginia Tech professor who is suing the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC) and unnamed donors after his offer of a tenured professorship in American Indian studies was withdrawn due to his hateful, anti-Semitic tweets.
A sampling includes such gems as, "I wish all the f—ing West Bank settlers would go missing"; "The @IDFSpokesperson is a lying motherf—er"; "Israel's message to Obama and Kerry: we'll kill as many Palestinians as we want, when we want. p.s.: f— you, pay me"; "By eagerly conflating Jewishness and Israel, Zionists are partly responsible when people say antisemitic sh— in response to Israeli terror"; and "If Netanyahu appeared on TV with a necklace made from the teeth of Palestinian children, would anybody be surprised?"
While Salaita's is one of the few cases of boorishness that resulted in consequences, the fact that so many of his peers rushed to his defense, going so far as to boycott UIUC, reveals the level of discourse that these "scholarly" organizations and individuals find acceptable. No doubt, Salaita's targeting of Israel inspired their protectiveness.
California State University, Stanislaus political science professor As'ad AbuKhalil combines crudeness with a lust for violence. Happily anticipating Israel's destruction, AbuKhalil wrote in 2012:
Speaking at the University of California, Berkeley in 2011, AbuKhalil reveled in the attacks on Israeli embassies in Egypt and throughout the region during the "Arab Spring":
Descending into outright bigotry towards Israelis and Jews, University of Michigan history professor Juan Cole, in 2014, decried the "undemocratic and cult-like" behavior of "Zionist organizations" and "Jewish nationalists . . . who misuse their public position[s] . . . to protect Israel from criticism or to punish its critics."
In 2004, Columbia University Iranian studies professor Hamid Dabashi, echoing classic anti-Semitism, said of "Israeli Jews," "the way they talk, walk, the way they greet each other, there is a vulgarity of character that is bone deep and structural to the skeletal vertebrae of its culture." Engaging in Holocaust inversion, Dabashi proclaimed in 2014 that, "From now on, every time any Israeli, every time any Jew, anywhere in the world, utters the word 'Auschwitz,' or the word 'Holocaust,' the world will hear 'Gaza.'"
Not to be outdone, Joseph Massad, professor of modern Arab politics and intellectual history at Columbia University, in 2009, compared what he called the "Gaza Ghetto Uprising" to the 1943 Warsaw Ghetto Uprising and, in 2014, described Israel as "the European Jewish-supremacist settler-colony" and the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) as "international Zionist Jewish brigades of baby-killers."
That such intellectual vulgarians fill the ranks of Middle East studies and educate students and the public on the intricacies of the region is a disgrace. The preponderance of these voices reflects the decline in academic discourse and the general coarsening of scholarship, a degeneration that shows no sign of abating. How much worse can it get? Sadly, we're likely to find out.
© 2002 - 2017 The Middle East Forum. Campus Watch contact e-mail: email@example.com